Buy your weekday smoothies and get your weekend ones for free. (7 for the price of 5!)
WELLNESSWEEK
The novelty shot category has a credibility problem. Walk through the back section of most liquor stores and you'll find shelves full of impulse purchases that nobody finishes: synthetic-sweet schnapps in novelty bottles, fluorescent shots designed around a pun rather than a flavor, and gift-set spirits that everyone laughs at and nobody pours twice.
But ask most adults what they actually want in a shot, and the answer is consistent: something with real flavor, something smooth enough to enjoy rather than endure, and something that doesn't taste like it was designed for a twenty-two-year-old's first bar experience.
Those products exist in the novelty category, from established names like Fireball to craft entries like Soda Jerk Root Beer Shot. You just have to know which ones are worth buying.
What Makes a Novelty Shot Worth Drinking?
A novelty shot earns its place on a back bar when it does two things: it delivers on its flavor concept, and it works as a real drinking experience rather than a one-time dare. A few practical filters:
- Does it taste like what it claims to be? Real flavor, not a synthetic approximation.
- Can you drink it neat without grimacing? Good novelty shots work straight.
- Would you buy a second bottle? If the answer is no after one pour, it's a novelty in the gimmick sense rather than the fun sense.
- Is there any real craft behind it? Blind-judged competition results are one of the few honest signals in this category.
Classic Novelty Shots Everyone Should Know
Before getting into what's worth buying, it helps to understand the classics. These are the shots that built the novelty category and still appear at bars and parties everywhere:
The Birthday Cake Shot
A whipped cream vodka base combined with a splash of Frangelico or hazelnut liqueur, sometimes with a sugared rim. The result actually resembles the flavor of vanilla birthday cake more than you'd expect. One of the more successful flavor concepts in the category because the key notes (vanilla, light nuttiness, sweetness) are all present and balanced.
Common recipe: 1 oz whipped cream vodka, 0.5 oz Frangelico, sugared rim. Shoot or sip over ice.
The Pickleback Shot
A shot of Irish whiskey (classically Jameson) followed immediately by a shot of pickle brine. It sounds terrible and tastes surprisingly good. The salt and acid of the pickle brine neutralizes the burn of the whiskey and leaves an oddly pleasant savory aftertaste. A genuine cult classic, born in Brooklyn bars around 2006 and now a fixture at dive bars everywhere.
It qualifies as novelty because of the concept, but it's actually one of the most drinkable shots on this list.
The Chocolate Cake Shot
Frangelico and citrus vodka, with a sugar-lemon chaser. The combination of hazelnut and citrus with sugar creates a flavor that genuinely registers as chocolate cake to most palates, which is one of the more impressive sleight-of-hand tricks in cocktail culture. Introduced at a New York bar in the 1980s and still widely made.
Recipe: 0.75 oz Frangelico, 0.75 oz citrus vodka. Shoot both, then immediately bite the lemon wedge dipped in sugar.
The Peanut Butter Whiskey Shot
Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey essentially created this as a standalone shot category when it launched in 2018. The spirit is sweeter and lower-proof than standard whiskey, with a genuinely convincing peanut butter note. Works neat, works over ice, works combined with Baileys or chocolate liqueur for a Reese's-adjacent experience.
The success of Skrewball proved that flavor-forward novelty spirits with real drinkability can break out of the gimmick category entirely. It's now one of the best-selling flavored whiskeys in the US.
The Washington Apple Shot
Crown Royal, sour apple schnapps, and cranberry juice in equal parts. A legitimate bar staple that's been around since the early 2000s. The apple and cranberry balance each other, the Crown adds warmth without harshness, and the result is a shot that actually has a complete flavor profile rather than just sweetness.
Recipe: equal parts Crown Royal Canadian Whisky, DeKuyper Sour Apple Pucker schnapps, and cranberry juice. Shake with ice, strain into shot glasses.
The Best Novelty Shots for Adults Who Want Something More
The classics above are well-established for a reason. But for adults who want something with a bit more craft behind it, a few newer options are worth knowing about.
Soda Jerk Root Beer Shot
The most credible entry in the nostalgic flavor spirits category. Built to taste like a root beer float, the spirit captures the vanilla and wintergreen character of real root beer at 35% ABV (70 proof). Smooth enough to drink neat, versatile enough to work in cocktails including the Root Beer Bomb (dropped into a cold beer), the Man Float (poured over vanilla ice cream), and a straightforward Cowboy Shot.
What separates it from most novelty spirits is the competition record. Gold Medal at the 2023 Los Angeles International Spirits Competition and Gold Medal at the 2021 San Francisco World Spirits Competition. Those competitions judge blind. The medals reflect flavor quality.
"We wanted a spirit people would actually reach for again. The root beer float is such a specific, nostalgic flavor memory for most people. Getting it right in a spirit took real work, and the competition results told us we got there." -- Craig Potter, co-founder and CEO of Soda Jerk Shot
Fireball Cinnamon Whisky
Unavoidable on any honest novelty shots list. Fireball is 33% ABV, cinnamon-forward, sweet but not as sweet as schnapps, and works both as a standalone shot and as a mixer. It earned its ubiquity by being genuinely enjoyable rather than just aggressively marketed, though the category it created has spawned plenty of inferior imitators.
The cinnamon heat means it does burn slightly, which is part of the point. If you want no burn at all, the other options on this list are better choices.
RumChata
A rum-based cream liqueur with cinnamon and vanilla notes, built around a horchata flavor concept. Smooth, sweet, and genuinely distinctive. Works as a shot, as a float ingredient, or combined with Fireball for a Cinnamon Toast Crunch shot that is far more enjoyable than it has any right to be.
Lower proof than most entries on this list (13.75% ABV), which makes it better suited as a component than a standalone shot for anyone who wants real proof.
Sugarlands Appalachian Banana Pudding Sippin' Cream
A Tennessee-made cream spirit with a banana pudding flavor profile. An unusual concept that works because banana and vanilla cream are a natural combination, and the Appalachian craft spirits heritage gives it more credibility than the name might suggest. Best served cold.
A Note on Shots Without the Burn
'No burn' is one of the most common things people search for when they're looking for novelty shots. The burn in a standard shot comes from the ethanol hitting the back of the throat, which is most pronounced in unflavored spirits at high proof.
Reducing the burn comes down to three things: proof level, flavor integration, and sweetness. Lower-proof spirits burn less. Spirits where the flavor is built into the distillation rather than added after the fact tend to be smoother because the flavor compounds buffer the ethanol. And sweetness masks burn, though it also masks everything else.
The best no-burn shots are usually in the 30 to 35% ABV range with enough real flavor to stand on their own. Soda Jerk Root Beer Shot, RumChata, and the Birthday Cake variation all fall into this range. Fireball burns a little by design. The classic recipe shots above will burn proportionally to the proof of the base spirit used.
What to Avoid in the Novelty Shot Category
A few red flags worth knowing when you're browsing the novelty section:
- Very low proof (under 15% ABV) usually means the product is more syrup than spirit and won't taste right as a shot.
- No flavor information on the label beyond a generic description suggests the producer isn't confident in the actual taste profile.
- Novelty packaging with no identifiable distillery or production origin is often a sign that the liquid is low-quality neutral spirit with added flavoring.
- Extreme sweetness often masks harshness rather than genuine smoothness. If it's very sweet and very cheap, the sweetness is doing the work.
The novelty shot category rewards some research before you buy. The products that have survived long enough to become classics, or that have earned blind competition recognition, are almost always the better choice over whatever is new and heavily marketed.
Gold Medal winner at the LA International Spirits and SF World Spirits Competitions. Smooth, nostalgic, and genuinely craft. Available in 50ml and 750ml.
Find a retailer or shop direct at sodajerk.com
